
If you have been reading my blogs, you probably have already figured out I am a hopeless reality TV junkie. But before you judge my viewing habits, let me give you a little history of the genre, in hopes that you will see these can be learning experiences.
If you have followed reality TV at all you might think that American "Reality TV" began with MTV's "Real World." You know the show...
"This is the true story... of seven strangers... picked to live in a house...work together and have their lives taped... to find out what happens... when people stop being polite... and start getting real...The Real World."It is the longest running program in MTV history.
But, dear reader, if you thought that, you would be wrong.
What started it all was a program on...steady yourself...PBS! So harumph!
It all began with "An American Family,"an American television documentary filmed in 1971 and first aired in the United States on PBS in early 1973. The show was twelve episodes long, edited down from about 300 hours of footage, and chronicled the experiences of a nuclear family, the Louds of Santa Barbara, California, during a period of time when parents Bill and Pat Loud separated and Pat filed for divorce. In 2002, "An American Family" was listed at #32 on TV Guide's 50 Greatest TV Shows of All Time list. It is one of the earliest examples of the "reality television" genre."
Here's more...After I saw that series, I was hooked on the drama that is inherent in everyday life.
And then the Big Daddy of what I would call "Entertainment/Reality TV" came along.
Survivor.
Survivor is credited with popularizing modern reality TV and, I guess, must take the blame for the likes of
Temptation Island and
Growing Up Gotti.But
Survivor's popularity is still strong, and it is probably because it really has it all. It is combination drama, reality TV, game show and endurance contest. What more could you ask for?
Now reality has moved into every genre you can imagine.
We have self improvement reality -
Biggest Loser and
The Swan.
Variety show reality -
American Idol,
So You Think You Can DanceHome Improvement Reality -
Trading Spaces,
Extreme Home MakeoverReal Estate Reality -
House Hunters,
Property VirginsCooking Reality -
Top Chef,
Hell's KitchenFashion Reality -
America's Next Top Model,
Project RunwayEven Gross Out Reality -
Fear FactorIt goes on and on. Quite overwhelming, right?
Well, good thing you have me.
I will help you sort out the best of the lot.
(Since Survivor is the granddaddy of them all, I will give it the Lifetime Achievement Award and leave it off my list).Best Reality TV shows 1.
Amazing Race
Best show for armchair travelers.
It was difficult to choose #1, but the
Amazing Race is the fastest hour on television. It has the drama of the interaction between the paired contestants, and the viewer gets to participate in the heart pumping race while at the same time see the world. Host Phil Keoghan seems to genuinely care about the players when he has to say to that episode's losers, "You are the last team to arrive. I am sorry to have to tell you, you have been eliminated from the race."
What you will learn: If your team constitutes "good TV" (i.e. lots of fighting or dumb moves), the powers that be will manipulate the outcome so your team can continue to be good TV (hence the couple of non-elimination rounds).
Here's more...2.
So you Think You Can Dance
American Idol for Dance.
But it is so much more classy than Idol. Yes, it has the auditions, but far fewer of the "bad" auditions that Idol has, which IMHO are interminable. All contestants are treated with great respect and the lowest scorers get to "dance for their lives" at the end of each episode. Dancers are probably the hardest working performers there are, so it's great to see them get a showcase.
What you will learn: You really do like to watch dancing.
So You Think You Can Dance3.
Intervention.I wish I could have been a fly on the wall when this was pitched to A & E.
"We have an idea for a show where a film crew follows around a drunk person and then her family holds an intervention. Whadjathink?"
But this program is one of the most compelling on television, reality show or not.
The format is the same. The addicted person thinks he or she is part of a documentary and has no idea there will soon be an intervention.
One thing I wonder about, though. This show has been on for a few years, so you would think when approached by a film crew there would be a suspicion that perhaps an intervention is nigh but so far, the subjects don't seem to have a clue. It is engrossing, heartbreaking and uplifting.
What you will learn: There is hope for even the most hardcore alcohol and drug addicted.
Intervention4.
Top Chef
Yum. Who knew the world of cooking could be so vicious and odd concoctions so delicious.
What you will learn: The good guy doesn't always win.
Top Chef5.
Project Runway
From Heidi's little girl "Hello" at the beginning to Tim Gunn's "Make it work," this is a fun peak into the world of fashion. It's your "put a bunch of people in a house together and see what happens" fun with a fashion show at the end. You would think this would be strictly a women's reality genre, but you would be surprised how many men watch this show!
What you will learn: Sometimes a really ugly dress is considered high fashion.
Project Runway6.
Dancing with the Stars
This is the ultimate showcase for the celebrity on the way up AND on the way down. Either way, being on this show will stimulate your career and you will lose weight at the same time.
What you will learn: You really do want to take ballroom dancing lessons.
7.
The Bachelor.
One guy - 25 women.
Sexist? Probably. Fun. Absolutely. My husband watches too, but he always says, "I feel dirty but I can't help myself." We watch just in case it really is going to be the "most dramatic rose ceremony ever."
What you will learn: "How do you solve a problem like Vienna?"
The Bachelor9.
The Biggest Loser
Who would think watching a bunch of overweight people get weighed would be a show? But here it is. Why do we watch?
For the ultimate pay off, when they have all lost as much as they can lose in 6 months of grueling workouts and low fat eating and are transformed. And it is amazing.
What you will learn: You aren't nearly as fat as they are.
The Biggest Loser OK so those are the cream of the crop.
I am sure you have your favorites, and I would love to hear about them.
But I feel I have to be honest with you and share some guilty pleasures.
There is a dark side to reality TV.
So here is a list of...dun dun dun...
The Best of the Worst Reality Shows1.
Rock of Love.

I love this show! Brett Michaels cares not that we may judge his taste in women. Strippers? Bring them on! Biker chicks? Yes! And Brett seems to truly get into these women. Not to mention what THEY get into when he's not around.
What you will learn: Nothing, but it's an hour of mindless fun.
Rock of Love2.
Beauty and the Geek.
Ashton Kutcher came up with this one. It is actually quite a sweet show. Smart geek learns to have fun from beautiful airhead. Beautiful airhead learns it's not that much fun to be an airhead. As time goes by, they all form a bond that is very endearing. Of course there is always a geek or two that only needs a different haircut to be handsome, but we will forgive that bit of a set up.
What you will learn: Women will go for homely smart men before homely men will go for homely women.
Beauty and the Geek3.
Big BrotherThis show started in Holland and has versions all over the world. The British version takes place every summer and the presenter opens with "Say Goodbye to your Summer, this is Big Brother!" And it's sort of like that. You need endurance for this one and a propensity for enjoying watching people sitting around, but if you hang in there, some drama will ensue. The celebrity version is especially fun.
What you will learn: What happens when people are really, really bored.
Big Brother 20105.
Real Chance of Love.This one is my guilty guilty pleasure, but when I found out my daughter was also watching it, I didn't feel so bad.
Now hang in there with me.
First there was
Flavor of Love, a show meant to match up Flavor Flav (and if you don't know who he is, probably none of this will make sense) with a woman, Bachelor style.
One of the women who was not chosen was plucked from obscurity by VH1 to have her own show. Her name was New York (Flav likes to give all of these women nicknames, some of which are not for your gentle ears), and the show was a Bachelorette-style show called
I Love New York.
Two brothers were vying for her love - Chance and Real (more nicknames). They too did not win the prize that was New York, but made enough of a splash to get their own show in which they could find love. Get it?
Real Chance of LoveA spin-off of a spin-off of a spin-off.
What you will learn: The lengths to which reality show mongers will go to wring out a show.
Real Chance of LoveSo there you have it. My entire inner life. Pathetic, I know, but if you ever have questions about pop culture, I'm your girl.
Oh, one more thing.
I forgot the most important reality show of all.The Library. Every day people come to us with their real needs. We will answer any question, help with everything from job hunting to finding that recipe on the Food Channel. We provide quality fun and enlightening programs for the whole family, offer tax help, citizenship classes, you name it. It's happening at the library.
And it's all real.Librarian: The Reality Series